Mary Beth Barone brought her signature charm and candid humor to the red carpet at the premiere of Overcompensating, the new comedy-drama series streaming on Amazon Prime Video. Held on May 14, the event celebrated creator and star Benito Skinner‘s semi-autobiographical journey through college life, identity, and self-discovery.
The Milk Challenge: A Moment of Triumph
Barone’s appearance on The Drew Barrymore Show became a viral sensation when she flawlessly chugged a massive glass of milk. Reflecting on the experience, she admitted to feeling nervous but was emboldened by Barrymore’s unwavering confidence in her abilities. “When I tip this glass back, I don’t know what’s going to happen,” Barone recalled, adding with a laugh, “But then with Drew’s confidence in me, I just felt like I could take on the world.” She jokingly added that seeing any glasses of milk on the red carpet would be “triggering” for her.
@thedrewbarrymoreshow “I am dairy-free for attention.” – @Mary Beth Barone 😂 #overcompensating @Benito Skinner @Wally Baram #primevideo
Milk, Mayhem, and Too Many Takes
Stepping into the role of Grace, Benny’s older, endlessly opinionated sister, was no small feat for Mary Beth Barone, who’s actually the youngest of six in real life. To nail the big sister energy, she worked with an acting coach and dove headfirst into sibling psychology. But nothing could prepare her for Episode 4, where chaos, and comedy, took over.
Barone recalled one scene in particular where her on-screen boyfriend Peter (played by Adam DiMarco) let loose with so much improvisation, she physically couldn’t keep it together. “He was jumping up and down, just so excited, and every take I broke,” she said. “I was like, ‘I think I’ve ruined the scene. I don’t think we have one usable take.’” Luckily, the magic of editing saved the moment—and likely a lot of blooper reel footage too.
View this post on Instagram
And when the conversation shifted to college, Barone didn’t hold back. She attended Boston College before transferring out and clearly still has a few wild stories tucked away. While she didn’t go into every detail, she hinted that her college years, like her comedy, involved unexpected turns and plenty of laughs.
The Premiere: A Night to Remember
The premiere event was a blend of glamour and excitement. After the screening of the first two episodes, attendees enjoyed themed merchandise, delectable snacks, and a surprise DJ set by Haim, turning the evening into an impromptu dance party. Cast members, including Wally Baram, Adam DiMarco, and Rish Shah, joined Barone on the carpet, celebrating the show’s launch.
About ‘Overcompensating’
Overcompensating follows Benny (Benito Skinner), a closeted former football player navigating his freshman year at Yates University. Seeking to fit in, he befriends Carmen (Wally Baram), a high school outsider. The series delves into themes of identity, self-discovery, and the lengths individuals go to in order to belong. The ensemble cast includes Mary Beth Barone as Grace, Adam DiMarco as Peter, and Rish Shah as Miles. The series is executive produced by Charli XCX and produced by A24 and Amazon MGM Studios.
You can also now stream all episodes of Overcompensating now on Amazon Prime Video.
