Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s office has dropped its lawsuit accusing the NCAA of deceptive marketing over transgender athletes in women’s sports. On Thursday, Nov. 12, the office told a state district court in Lubbock that it would not proceed with the case, the Texas Tribune reported.
Bloomberg Law, which first reported the filing, said Paxton “abandoned all claims in the nearly two-year-old suit without prejudice.” Dropping claims without prejudice generally leaves a party free to refile them later. Neither Bloomberg Law nor the Tribune reported a reason for the move. Bloomberg Law said Paxton’s office didn’t answer its request for comment on Friday.
What Paxton’s NCAA Lawsuit Claimed in December 2024
Paxton announced the case on Sunday, Dec. 22, 2024, under the Deceptive Trade Practices Act, the state’s consumer-protection law.
“When people watch a women’s volleyball game, for example, they expect to see women playing against other women,” Paxton said in a news release from his office. He argued that fans buying tickets to “women’s” events were misled if a transgender woman might be on the field or court.
The suit, according to the release, asked the court either to bar trans women from women’s events in Texas or involving Texas teams, or to make the NCAA stop calling those events “women’s” competitions.
The NCAA said at the time that it “does not comment on pending litigation.” “College sports are the premier stage for women’s sports in America,” it said in a statement quoted by The Associated Press via ABC News. That same AP report noted NCAA President Charlie Baker had told Congress earlier that month that he knew of fewer than 10 active NCAA athletes who identified as transgender, out of roughly 544,000.
The NCAA’s February 2025 Policy Change and the Sex-Screening Fight
President Donald Trump signed Executive Order 14201, titled “Keeping Men Out of Women’s Sports,” on Feb. 5, 2025. A day later, the NCAA changed its rules.
“The new policy limits competition in women’s sports to student-athletes assigned female at birth only,” the NCAA’s announcement said.
“This national standard brings much-needed clarity,” Baker said.
Paxton wasn’t satisfied. Later that month, he added a filing to the Lubbock case asking a judge to order the NCAA to screen athletes’ sex, The Associated Press reported. Judge Les Hatch of the 237th District Court denied the state’s request for a temporary injunction in March 2025, just as March Madness began, Bloomberg Law reported.
The NCAA then asked Hatch to end the case. Its lawyer, Victor Vital, wrote that “the perceived controversy the AG seeks to litigate no longer exists,” Lubbock Lights reported in May. Another NCAA filing argued, “it would be fundamentally unfair to now hold the NCAA liable.”
In May 2026, Hatch granted the NCAA summary judgment on the state’s bid for court-ordered sex testing, Bloomberg Law reported. The consumer-protection claims survived that ruling, and Paxton’s office dropped them last week.
Paxton’s Office Drops FIEL and Annunciation House Cases, Too
Paxton lost his U.S. Senate bid in the Nov. 3 election. Democratic state Sen. Nathan Johnson beat Republican Mayes Middleton for attorney general the same night.
The NCAA suit is one of several the office has let go since. “Earlier this week, Paxton’s office dropped a lawsuit seeking to shut down FIEL,” the Texas Tribune reported on Nov. 13. FIEL is a Houston immigrant-rights group. “The office also dropped a lawsuit seeking to shut down Annunciation House,” an El Paso migrant shelter, the Tribune said.
Paxton stays attorney general until Johnson takes over in January, so the filings came from his office.
“We need to devote resources to a function that has been neglected in favor of running a partisan agenda,” Johnson told KXAN. The station reported that he has promised to review Paxton-era lawsuits and investigations. He said he won’t pursue cases that are “purely political.”
Gayety has reported on why some trans Texans see reasons to be optimistic after the election. But Paxton’s office has not explained why it dropped this lawsuit. The timing alone does not establish its reason.
The NCAA’s current policy still bars athletes assigned male at birth from competing on women’s teams. It permits practice consistent with an athlete’s gender identity, subject to other eligibility requirements. The lawsuit’s withdrawal does not change those rules.
