Get ready for another semester of secrets, self-discovery, and signature sarcasm, ‘Overcompensating‘ is officially returning for a second season.
Prime Video has renewed the breakout college comedy, created by and starring Benito Skinner, following a strong debut in May that resonated with audiences and critics alike. The show, which centers around a closeted former high school football star navigating the chaos of college life, marks Skinner’s first scripted TV series and has quickly become a Gen Z cult favorite.
“I have been so overwhelmed by the insane response to the show, and feel so damn lucky to go back to Yates University with Amazon MGM Studios, A24, Strong Baby, and this legendary cast for season two,” Skinner said in a statement following the renewal news.
Overcompensating is produced by A24, Amazon MGM Studios, and Strong Baby, the production company helmed by Jonah Hill. Hill, along with Matt Dines and Ali Goodwin, serves as an executive producer on the series.
A Coming-of-Age Story with Heart and Hilarity
The show follows Benny, played by Skinner, a closeted ex-football star and former homecoming king who arrives at the fictional Yates University looking to leave his past behind. There, he meets Carmen (Wally Baram), a fiercely awkward yet endearing outsider desperate to fit in. The two form an unlikely friendship that fuels much of the show’s heart and humor.
Through satirical takes on frat culture, hookup apps, and identity politics, the series explores themes of masculinity, queerness, and the pressure to perform—the title itself a not-so-subtle nod to Benny’s internal struggles.
In addition to Skinner and Baram, the ensemble cast includes Mary Beth Barone, Adam DiMarco, Rish Shah, Holmes, Corteon Moore, Owen Thiele, and Nell Verlaque, all of whom round out the fictional college’s student body with dynamic, chaotic, and deeply lovable characters.
From Viral Videos to Scripted Stardom
For longtime fans of Benito Skinner, the leap from Instagram reels and YouTube sketches to a full-blown TV series has felt both inevitable and well-deserved. Known for his sharp, pop culture-driven comedy (and iconic alter ego “Benny Drama”), Skinner has long blended humor with personal storytelling. Overcompensating is, in many ways, his most personal project yet.
“From the very beginning, Benito brought us a vision that was fearless, hilarious, and deeply personal,” said Sam French, head of U.S. television at A24. “It’s been amazing to see audiences around the world connect with his story and we’re thrilled to continue this journey with him, Scott King, our partners at Prime Video, and Strong Baby.”
The series is executive produced by Skinner, Scott King (who also serves as showrunner), Josh Bachove, Daniel Gray Longino, and none other than Charli XCX, who also holds the title of executive music producer, helping curate the show’s distinctly queer, high-energy soundtrack.
The Response? Loud, Proud, and Positive
Overcompensating premiered on Prime Video in May 2025 and quickly generated buzz for its refreshingly honest, and often hilarious, portrayal of queerness in college life. With glowing reviews from outlets including The Hollywood Reporter, the show was praised for balancing biting satire with genuine emotional depth.
Skinner’s portrayal of Benny, a character both painfully relatable and laugh-out-loud funny, struck a chord with viewers navigating their own journeys with identity and belonging.
“We look forward to our global Prime Video customers enjoying more of Benito’s captivating and bold storytelling in the second season,” said Vernon Sanders, global head of television at Prime Video and Amazon MGM Studios. “Working alongside the talented teams from A24 and Strong Baby has been a joy for everyone involved, and we are excited to see what hilarious moments Benito has planned for season two.”
The show’s renewal comes at a time when authentic LGBTQ+ storytelling is increasingly vital in the entertainment landscape. By putting queer narratives front and center—without making them the butt of the joke, Overcompensating offers representation that is both affirming and hilariously real.
What’s Next at Yates University?
While plot details for Season 2 are still under wraps, fans can expect even more absurd campus antics, emotional breakthroughs, and maybe, just maybe, Benny coming a little closer to embracing his true self.
Given the first season’s success, the stakes are high, but Skinner and his creative team seem more than ready to deliver. Whether you’re reliving your own college cringe or just in it for the messy queer joy, Overcompensating is proving to be one of Prime Video’s brightest new offerings.
Season 1 of Overcompensating is currently streaming on Prime Video.
