Sports

Transgender Fencer Sues USA Fencing and a Fairfax Academy Under Virginia Law

Dinah Yukich says USA Fencing and Fairfax County’s Fencing Sports Academy broke Virginia’s public-accommodations law by keeping her out of a women’s event.

Two fencers in white uniforms and masks face off on a strip in an indoor gym with tall windows

Tima Miroshnichenko/Pexels

A transgender fencer has sued USA Fencing and the Fencing Sports Academy in Fairfax County Circuit Court, claiming they broke Virginia’s public-accommodations law by barring her from women’s competition. FOX 5 DC reported the lawsuit Monday, citing court documents.

The plaintiff is Dinah Yukich, whom FOX 5 described as “a Maryland woman.” She wants a court to order the academy to follow Virginia law and award no more than $75,000 in damages, and says the defendants conspired to keep her out of events, the station reported.

“Virginia state law is clear that businesses and events that are open to the public cannot post, publish, or circulate a policy that says someone is not welcome because of who they are,” her lawyer, Susie Cirilli, told the station.

FOX 5 did not provide a filing date or case number. Her claims haven’t been tested in court.

What the Fairfax Fencing Lawsuit Alleges

The dispute centers on a USA Fencing-sanctioned event at the Fairfax academy in January. Yukich tried to switch her USA Fencing membership from male to female to enter, and the organization changed it back, FOX 5 reported.

Her driver’s license, Social Security records and birth certificate now list her as female, and when she contacted the academy, it said it had to defer to USA Fencing, according to the station.

Cirilli likened the policy to a sign in a business’s window. “So these bans in sports, these flat-out bans of people, have the same effect of putting a sign in the window saying trans people not welcome, trans people need not apply, trans people use the back entrance, or trans people can’t sit at the lunch counter,” she told FOX 5.

Before suing, Yukich “first filed a claim with the state attorney general,” FOX 5 reported. Under Va. Code § 2.2-3907, a person “may file” a complaint with the “Office of Civil Rights of the Department of Law,” part of the attorney general’s office. A related section generally allows a lawsuit only after that office issues a notice of the right to sue or 180 days pass.

The station asked Cirilli about critics who believe “there is a measurable difference between women and men, especially when it comes to sports.” She answered with the statute. “The law is what it is. The law says if something is open to the public, you cannot exclude based on a protected class,” she said.

Virginia Human Rights Act Covers ‘Gender Identity’

The case leans on Va. Code § 2.2-3904. It defines a public accommodation as “all places or businesses offering or holding out to the general public goods, services, privileges, facilities, advantages, or accommodations.”

“Sex,” “sexual orientation,” and “gender identity” are among the grounds on which the section bars denying anyone those services. Cirilli’s “post, publish, or circulate” line echoes a second clause, which makes it unlawful to “publish, circulate, issue, display, post, or mail” a notice that someone will be refused.

The section “shall not apply to a private club” or any establishment “that is not in fact open to the public.”

A court may award a winning plaintiff “compensatory and punitive damages” under § 2.2-3908, plus attorney fees and an injunction.

USA Fencing Says It Lacks ‘Discretion to Deviate’

USA Fencing told FOX 5 it couldn’t comment on pending litigation but sent a statement. “More generally, as the recognized National Governing Body for fencing in the United States, USA Fencing is required to comply with athlete eligibility standards set by the U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee and the International Fencing Federation. We do not have discretion to deviate from those requirements.”

The Fencing Sports Academy declined to comment to FOX 5, and Yukich declined to speak with the station.

USA Fencing’s current eligibility policy took effect Aug. 1, 2025, after the USOPC told every national governing body to align with President Donald Trump’s February 2025 “Keeping Men Out of Women’s Sports” executive order. Its women’s category covers “athletes who are of the female sex at birth and have not started female-to-male hormone treatment.” The men’s category is “open to all athletes not eligible for the Women’s Category, including transgender women.”

The same policy page addresses state law. “It is important to note that there may be existent laws per state, and an evolving federal legal landscape that have implications on the adherence to the proposed policy,” it says. “In such cases, it is the responsibility of that event host(s) or individual(s) to make USA Fencing aware.”

Dinah Yukich’s New Jersey and Maryland Cases

Virginia is Yukich’s third venue. In October 2025, she sued USA Fencing, the USOPC and Premier Fencing Club after she couldn’t register for a women’s event in New York. Her complaint opened: “Dinah Yukich is a woman who loves to fence,” according to a Villanova sports law journal analysis. That filing says she began transitioning in 2021, Sport Resolutions reported.

Yukich called the USOPC-driven policy “demeaning and offensive,” per Sport Resolutions. Cirilli told The Athletic that “the USOPC and USAF (USA Fencing) worked together and conspired to ensure that transgender women were excluded from women’s competitions,” the dispute-resolution group reported.

A federal judge in New Jersey threw out her claims against USA Fencing and the USOPC on jurisdiction grounds, Bloomberg Law reported Oct. 1. The court found she hadn’t shown New Jersey was where she “felt the brunt of that alleged conduct.”

She also filed a complaint with the Maryland Commission on Civil Rights over March’s Cherry Blossom Open at the University of Maryland, The Daily Record reported in May. “When you host an event where members of the public can participate, you have to follow state law,” Cirilli told that paper. She said the Johns Hopkins fencing coach didn’t want “girly men” on his team when she tried out in college, the paper reported.

Virginia voters approved Question 2 this month. It’s set to strip the 2006 marriage ban from the state constitution on Jan. 1, 2027. Fairfax County’s school district is one of those in the 4th Circuit’s revived Title IX fight with the Trump administration.

As of Monday night, nobody had reported a hearing date in the Fairfax case.

Gayety on Substack

Get More From Gayety

For the stories we can’t show you here, head over to Gayety on Substack.

Join on Substack (opens in a new tab)

More Stories