“The Fantasticks” opened on Broadway on Monday, Nov. 16, at the Hayes Theater, more than six decades after its Off-Broadway debut. This time, the two young lovers next door are Matt and Lewis.
The Second Stage Theater production uses Tom Jones’ revised book and lyrics, with Harvey Schmidt’s music. The neighboring fathers who trick their kids into falling in love are now mothers. “Boy-meets-girl is now boy-meets-boy, and we meet the pair’s mothers, not their fathers,” Joe Dziemianowicz wrote in his New York Theatre Guide review.
Christopher Gattelli is both the director and the choreographer. The limited run is set to end Feb. 7, 2027, Broadway News reported.
Flint Repertory Theatre Staged the Gay ‘Fantasticks’ First, in 2022
Michigan got a Matt and Lewis retelling first. The same-sex version played Flint Repertory Theatre from June 3 to June 19, 2022, Playbill reported.
“Transforming the boy and the girl into two boys (Matt and Lewis) is an idea I’ve had for a long time,” Michael Lluberes, then Flint Rep’s producing artistic director, said in Playbill’s announcement. He directed that production and developed the rewrite with Jones. “I had great fun doing it. I hope people have great fun viewing it,” Jones said.
The version later played Provincetown Playhouse in Massachusetts and Coachella Valley Repertory in Cathedral City, California, before Second Stage picked it up.
Sadly, Jones died in 2023, just a year after the queer revision premiered in Michigan.
He passed Aug. 11, 2023, at his home in Sharon, Connecticut, at 95, according to The Associated Press. His original show opened in 1960 at the Sullivan Street Playhouse, “finally closing in 2002 after 17,162 performances,” the AP wrote. It reopened in 2006 at the Snapple Theater Center and ran there until 2017.
What Critics Said About Matt and Lewis
Adam Feldman gave it four stars in Time Out New York. “‘The Fantasticks’ is a bouquet,” he wrote. He liked how little fuss the show makes over its couple: “Otherwise, the fact that both lovers are boys is treated with lovely nonchalance.”
Dziemianowicz landed in a similar place. The moms feud over gardening, he wrote, but “their gay sons are a total non-issue.”
Melissa Rose Bernardo of New York Stage Review also gave four stars, and described the change in two halves. “Ideologically, it’s a big change; dramaturgically, it’s surprisingly small,” she wrote. “The structure and soul of the show remain untouched.”
That smallness is what bothered David Gordon at TheaterMania, whose review called the show a gay old time that isn’t gay enough. Gordon wrote that Levy is “let down by Jones’s revisions, which change the character’s name and pronouns without meaningfully considering how a young gay man might act in these situations.” His blunter version: a more contemporary set of eyes might have gone further, but “what Levy is given is just Louisa by any other name.”
Bernardo’s colleague David Finkle gave three stars and found the boys’ love affair “tepid,” according to BroadwayWorld’s review roundup. In USA Today, Patrick Ryan said the show “feels like an antidote to an industry that’s increasingly allergic to simple, earnest storytelling,” per the same roundup.
‘The Fantasticks’ Broadway Cast and Creative Team
Maxim Chlumecky plays Matt and Nathan Levy plays Lewis, per the cast list in Playbill’s review roundup. Gordon called Chlumecky “a genuine star with charisma to spare,” and Feldman said the two leads are “fresh-faced, strong-voiced and sweet.”
Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer plays Matt’s mother, Mildred Hucklebee. Ruthie Ann Miles plays Lewis’ mother, Bessie Mae Bellomy. Feldman wrote that the pair “are a hoot and three quarters as the moms.” Dziemianowicz called Kritzer “a head-to-toe comic ace.”
Zane Phillips is El Gallo, the narrator who sings “Try to Remember.” Kevin Del Aguila (Mortimer), David Patrick Kelly (Henry) and Ahmad Simmons (The Mute) round out the company.
Jason Sherwood designed the sets and Linda Cho the costumes, with lighting by Jen Schriever and sound by Nevin Steinberg, per Second Stage. Sam Davis handles music supervision and orchestrations.
“I think there’s an expectation to modernize it,” Levy said in an October Playbill feature on the cast. Despite the gender swaps, Playbill wrote, the production has “really maintained the same original text.”
Elsewhere on Broadway this season, Michelle Visage is set for her Broadway debut in “Schmigadoon!”, and Margaret Cho is narrating “Rocky Horror Show”.
How to See ‘The Fantasticks’ Before It Closes Feb. 7
Second Stage sells tickets on its site and by phone at 212-541-4516 for the Hayes, at 240 W. 44th St. New York Theatre Guide put the starting price at $65, and Second Stage lists $25 to $35 rush tickets plus $30 tickets for patrons under 30.
Plan on 2 hours and 5 minutes, with one 15-minute intermission, according to Second Stage.
Previews began Oct. 22, with the show running through February 7, 2027.






