Montana cannot enforce its new law defining sex as strictly male or female while a legal challenge continues. Missoula County District Judge Leslie Halligan temporarily blocked SB 437 on Tuesday, saying the people challenging it are likely to prove it violates their constitutional rights to privacy and equal protection, Montana Free Press reported.
That would be the second time Halligan has ruled against a Montana sex-definition law. Halligan wrote that “plaintiffs are likely to succeed on claims that SB 437 violates the rights to privacy and equal protection,” the outlet reported.
The order is not a final ruling. It bars enforcement while the lawsuit is ongoing, unless Halligan lifts it or a higher court overturns it.

What Montana’s SB 437 Says About Sex and Gender
Sen. Carl Glimm, R-Kila, sponsored the bill. Under the enrolled text, “sex” means whether someone is male or female, based on the type of gamete a person is “capable of or expected to produce, as dictated by their primary sexual anatomy.”
The bill adds that a person’s sex “is in no way influenced or defined by one’s psychological state, behavior, expression, or personal identity.”
It also rewrites the word “gender.” When used alone, gender “must be considered a synonym for sex,” the text says, and it “may not be considered a synonym or shorthand expression for gender identity, experienced gender, gender expression, or gender role.”
Those definitions reach more than 60 sections of state law, Montana Free Press reported in March, including driver’s licenses, marriage licenses and anti-discrimination protections. Rep. Zooey Zephyr, D-Missoula, told the outlet the law erases intersex, nonbinary and Two Spirit people “from cradle to grave.” Gayety’s guide to nonbinary identity and X markers explains how sex markers on IDs already vary by state.
Why SB 437 Sat Unsigned for Nearly a Year
The Legislature passed SB 437 in April 2025. It then remained unsigned on House Speaker Brandon Ler’s desk until March 2026.
A House Republican spokesperson told Montana Free Press that legislative leaders delayed the bill to avoid entangling it in the existing SB 458 litigation.
Ler signed it March 24, 2026, and Gov. Greg Gianforte signed it the same day, Montana Free Press reported, citing the legislative record. The enrolled title gives it an immediate effective date.
Upper Seven Law litigation director Molly Danahy pointed to that delay in a press release after Tuesday’s ruling, Montana Free Press reported. Danahy called the maneuvering “extraordinary procedural shenanigans” that still couldn’t save the bill from ordinary constitutional review.
Judge Halligan Compares SB 437 to the Struck-Down SB 458
Upper Seven Law represents transgender, intersex and Two Spirit Montanans challenging the law. The plaintiffs filed their complaint on April 6, and the court heard the preliminary-injunction request June 19, Montana Free Press reported.
The state disagreed. It argued SB 437 differs from the 2023 law and doesn’t require anyone to hand over private information, Montana Free Press reported.
Halligan wrote that the question isn’t whether SB 437 uses “precisely the same words” as SB 458. She found its “operative effect” is the same: a “state-mandated binary classification of sex,” which her earlier ruling had already found unconstitutional.
How Courts Ruled on Montana’s Earlier Law
SB 458, the 2023 law, faced two separate adverse trial-court rulings. One found a problem with its title in June 2024. Halligan’s February 2025 ruling found that it violated the Montana Constitution’s equal-protection guarantee, according to Montana Free Press.
The latest injunction concerns SB 437, the replacement law. It temporarily blocks enforcement while the litigation continues. It is not a final judgment resolving that law’s constitutionality.
How the State Responded
The governor’s office pointed The Montana Free Press to a March 31 statement from Gianforte and Ler. It says the law “codifies the long-recognized, commonsense, immutable, biologically-based definition of sex, male and female.”
“The State of Montana will defend this duly enacted law and ensure it gets a fair hearing in Montana’s judiciary,” the statement says.
The governor’s office referred Montana Free Press to that statement rather than offering a new comment on the litigation. Halligan’s preliminary injunction blocks enforcement of SB 437 while the case proceeds, unless the order is changed by the court or overturned on appeal.






