Entertainment

Johnny Depp’s Jack Sparrow ‘Gay’ Story Returns in a New Biography

Mark Seal’s Depp biography says Disney executives asked if Jack Sparrow was ‘gay.’ Depp’s reply, ‘all of my characters are gay,’ echoes a line he’s told since 2010.

Johnny Depp smiles in glasses at The Tourist premiere in Tokyo in 2011.

Johnny Depp in Tokyo, March 3, 2011. Photo: matsubokkuri/Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0 (creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/); cropped.

Johnny Depp’s Jack Sparrow had Disney executives asking whether the pirate was “gay,” according to Mark Seal’s biography “The Many Faces of Johnny Depp.” The Hollywood Reporter published an excerpt Nov. 16, ahead of the book’s Nov. 24 release.

In the excerpt, Depp answers that question: “I’m sorry, didn’t you know all of my characters are gay?”

Simon & Schuster lists the biography at 400 pages, published by its Gallery Books imprint. Seal also wrote “Leave the Gun, Take the Cannoli,” about the making of “The Godfather.”

What Mark Seal’s Book Says Disney Asked About Jack Sparrow

The excerpt goes back to the making of “Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl,” released in 2003. Seal relays the questions that alarmed executives, who traded in phone calls about Depp’s take on the character. One was “Is he just incredibly drunk?”

“Or is he gay?” was another, according to Seal.

The excerpt doesn’t name the executive who asked. Nobody at Disney is quoted saying it on the record. The account is from the book, not a statement from the studio.

Seal also writes that Michael Eisner, then Disney’s chief executive, “reportedly shrieked” that “Depp is ruining the film!”

The executives worried about more than the swagger, according to the excerpt. Depp’s gold-capped teeth came up in a meeting with Dick Cook, then chairman of the Walt Disney Motion Picture Group. Cook wanted the audience focused on Depp’s eyes rather than his teeth, Seal writes.

Nina Jacobson, then a top Disney film executive, asked Depp what he was doing. “You got to trust me,” he told her, according to the book.

“Nobody had made a successful pirate movie,” Jacobson is quoted saying in the excerpt.

Producer Jerry Bruckheimer backed Depp, in Seal’s account. “You don’t hire Johnny Depp to put him in a box,” he said after a lunch with Depp in Paris, according to the excerpt.

Depp Told the ‘All My Characters Are Gay’ Story in 2010 and 2015

The line in Seal’s book isn’t new. Depp has been telling versions of it publicly for 16 years.

In a Vanity Fair interview with Patti Smith published in late 2010, Depp said Disney didn’t like his Sparrow. “They couldn’t stand him. They just couldn’t stand him,” he said, as CBS News and The Associated Press reported.

“I think it was Michael Eisner, the head of Disney at the time, who was quoted as saying, ‘He’s ruining the movie,'” Depp said in the same interview, Today reported.

He described the calls he got from the studio. “Is he drunk? By the way, is he gay?” Depp recalled being asked. His answer then was, “But didn’t you know that all my characters are gay?”

Depp said that answer “really made her nervous,” the AP reported. The report didn’t name the executive.

He told it again at AFI Fest on Nov. 8, 2015. “Well, don’t you know all my characters are gay?” Depp said he’d replied, Yahoo News reported.

“I really expected to be fired, but I wasn’t for some reason,” Depp told the festival audience, according to Moviefone. “They were actually gonna put subtitles under my character; they couldn’t understand Captain Jack.”

Trailer: Walt Disney Pictures via Rotten Tomatoes Classic Trailers.

Jack Sparrow, Queer Readings and the Oscar Nomination

Disney never fired him. “The Curse of the Black Pearl” earned five Academy Award nominations, including best actor for Depp, according to the Academy’s 2004 ceremony page. Sean Penn won that award for “Mystic River.”

Gayety put the franchise on its list of movies that set off bi panic, saying Depp’s Sparrow “had us cackling one second and swooning the next.” The real history of the high seas has its own queer pirates of the Golden Age.

Depp’s remark was a quip about his characters. It isn’t a statement about his own sexuality, and the book excerpt doesn’t present it as one.

“The Many Faces of Johnny Depp” goes on sale Tuesday, Nov. 24.

Gayety on Substack

Get More From Gayety

For the stories we can’t show you here, head over to Gayety on Substack.

Join on Substack (opens in a new tab)

More Stories