A federal appeals court refused Nov. 17 to put its June ruling in Talbott v. United States on hold, and protections took effect for the transgender troops already serving who sued over President Donald Trump’s ban.
The government’s “motion to stay issuance of the mandate pending the filing and disposition of a petition for a writ of certiorari” got one line in the D.C. Circuit’s order, filed Nov. 17: “it is ORDERED that the motion be denied.”
“The Clerk is directed to issue the mandate forthwith,” the order goes on. The mandate was filed that same day.
The panel divided 2-1. Judges Robert Wilkins and Judith Rogers denied the stay. A footnote reads: “Circuit Judge Walker would grant this motion.” Walker, a Trump appointee, had dissented in June as well, arguing that judges lack the power to second-guess the decision to exclude transgender troops, according to the AP.
The June panel found the ban likely violates equal protection. This is a preliminary injunction, not a final trial judgment. “That narrow interim relief does not harm the Government,” the plaintiffs told the justices.
Only Named Talbott Transgender Troops Are Shielded
The injunction protects named plaintiffs who were already serving when Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s policy took effect. Shannon Minter, legal director of the National Center for LGBTQ Rights, called them “decorated troops who have met every standard the military sets,” according to the AP.
Plaintiffs’ attorneys put the group at 27, the AP reported in wire copy carried by WJLA, while their Nov. 2 Supreme Court brief says 28.
The panel’s June 1 ruling left out people trying to enlist, as Gayety reported then.
Judge Ana Reyes later granted class certification after a June 30 hearing, according to the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse case summary. Even so, Wilkins wrote, the panel “affirmed the District Court’s injunction only as to the retention of specified plaintiffs.”
This order does not shield other trans service members from the Hegseth policy. Some Marines lost extension waivers even after review boards voted to keep them.
Wilkins: ‘Executive Prerogative’ Isn’t Irreparable Harm
Wilkins wrote that “the government has not alleged any irreparable harm that will result from retention of the currently serving Plaintiffs.”
Blocking a presidential policy isn’t harm by itself, he added. “So it cannot be that a mere assertion of executive prerogative suffices to show irreparable harm.”
He also quoted Rogers’ separate June opinion, which found the policy “appears designed to target a group of disfavored people, not to address a particular medical condition.”
Shilling’s ‘Universal Injunction’ Versus Talbott’s Narrow One
“Shilling involved a universal injunction that barred enforcement of the Hegseth Policy on retention and accession,” Wilkins wrote.
In United States v. Shilling, a Washington state case, the justices stayed a preliminary injunction on May 6, 2025, and let the policy take effect, the ABA Journal reported. Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson would have denied that request.
In Talbott, Wilkins said, “this injunction has been narrowed to cover only a limited group of currently serving Plaintiffs.”
Sauer’s Talbott Petition Heads to Dec. 4 Conference
“That gravely erroneous holding warrants this Court’s review,” Solicitor General D. John Sauer wrote in the government’s petition for a writ of certiorari, filed Aug. 27.
The docket for No. 26-272 shows the government’s reply arriving Nov. 16 and the case distributed Nov. 17 for the justices’ Dec. 4 private conference. A conference listing is not a decision to hear the case.
The government could also ask the justices to pause the mandate through a separate emergency application, the route it took in Shilling.
“The Trump administration asked the court to let it keep pushing these service members toward the door while it tries to get a different answer from the Supreme Court,” Minter said. “Today, the D.C. Circuit said no.”
Back in Washington, Reyes’ courtroom is headed toward a full trial on the merits. According to the plaintiffs’ brief, “a trial is set for January 4, 2027.”






